Monday, June 6, 2011

2011 Korea Australs - AIDA President introduces AIDA to new institutions

In an email sent over the weekend, Duncan Campbell, incumbent President of the AustralAsian Intervarsity Debating Association, (AIDA) introduced new institutions and institutional representatives to the basic ins and outs of AIDA, and each institution's responsibilities. These responsibilities are discussed detail in the AIDA Constitution.

Introduction to AIDA

What is AIDA?
AIDA is the AustralAsian Intervarsity Debating Association that governs the AustralAsian Invervarsity Debating Competition.  

AIDA Council consists of members of the AIDA Executive (non-voting members) and delegates of registered member institutions at the tournament.  Each institution has one vote.  Other people are welcome to come and participate in the discussion as observers.

What is the membership fee for 2011-2012?
Registration for July 2011 – July 2012 will be determined at the Pre-Council meeting. In the past few years, registration has been set at 50 Australian Dollars and is usually paid in AUD or currency local to the country where the tournament is held eg. South Korean Won.  Each institution must affiliate to AIDA for 2011-12 to have voting rights on Council.

Who are the institutional delegates?
It is up to each debating society to determine for themselves who their representative is.  Often the President of the debating society, or the External Officer of the society will represent their institution at AIDA, however, it is up to the institution to select a representative.  A different delegate can attend the pre-council and council meetings if a single delegate is not available for both meetings.

Controversial issues to be discussed at council (things like Constitutional amendments) should generally have some notice to enable institutional reps to consult with their society's executives and/or members.  However, this is up to your society and is not governed by AIDA!

What is the Pre-Council meeting?
The Pre-Council is the meeting held before the start of the debating rounds.  At this meeting eligibility issues are determined.  Institutions in breach of the n-1 or AA requirement may apply for exemptions and the penalty for a breach will be determined.  Pre-Council also sets the agenda for the main council meeting.

What is the Council meeting?
The Council meeting selects the next host for Australs, considers Constitutional issues and other issues related to debating and the Australs tournament.

Are there proxies at AIDA Council meetings?
Delegates from institutions may hold a maximum of one proxy from another institution that is present at the tournament.  Executive members and observers may not hold proxies.  Proxies must be from registered member institutions (ie. the institution must have paid its AIDA registration fee for 2011-12).  Institutions wishing to proxy should email the AIDA executive before the tournament nominating which institution they would like to hold their proxy.

Do I have to come to AIDA Council?
Yes! Every institution should send a representative to AIDA Council.

What is the Disputes Tribunal?
Any participant, Org Comm member or Executive member may request a meeting of the Disputes Tribunal to hear a complaint in relation to the Code of Conduct at an AIDA tournament.

The Tribunal is comprised of the AIDA President (or any other member of the AIDA Executive in his or her absence), the Convenor of the Championship, the Chief Adjudicator of the Championship and two other delegates randomly drawn.  (Any interested person should disqualify himself or herself.)

The Tribunal must attempt to hear all parties to the complaint and give each party a reasonable opportunity to state his or her case.  The tribunal should attempt to conciliate the dispute.  Where this cannot be done the Tribunal should make a determination.  The Tribunal may make determinations that vary from disposing of the complaint, to issuing a warning, to expelling the party complained against from the tournament. Obviously the seriousness of the determination will depend on the seriousness of the Code of Conduct breach.

Further details about the process of the Disputes Tribunal can be found in the Constitution.

Questions?
Feel free to email decampbell@gmail.com for any questions before Australs. Otherwise, if you have any questions about AIDA during Australs 2011, please come and speak to Duncan Campbell during the tournament.


---------------
Follow us on Twitter @debateIndonesia
Write to us at editorial.board.idebate@gmail.com

2011 SODE Results - UGM Alumni take the crown

Team Universitas Gajah Mada A (Caessar P, Astri Agustina, and Novel - most of whom are EDS UGM alumni) were crowned champions at last night's Surabaya Open Debate Event (SODE) after edging fellow finalist Angry Cock (comprised of Sony Lewi (ex-EDS UI), Rizal Kuddah (SCuD) and Erwin Susetyo (SMA 1 Sidoarjo) ).



Best Speaker of the tournament was Astri Agustina of UGM A.

The 2011 SODE was co-hosted by SMA 2 Surabaya and the Surabaya Community of Debaters ( SCuD) and followed the Asian parliamentary style.  It had 4 preliminary rounds, and 4 elimination rounds.  It is open to teams of all compositions.

Thanks to Rizal Kuddah and Caessar for the updates


---------------
Follow us on Twitter @debateIndonesia
Write to us at editorial.board.idebate@gmail.com

Thursday, June 2, 2011

2011 WSDC - Prepared Motions launched

As previously announced, the WSDC Prepared motions were released yesterday at midday GMT (6pm in Indonesia).

The Prepared Motions and their corresponding rounds are as follows:

Round 1  This House would offer dictators immunity in return for leaving power
Round 3  This House believes that Universal Primary Education is a misallocation of resources for the  
                developing world
Round 5  This House would legalise the sale of human organs
Round 7  This House believes that women can only achieve equality under a secular system of government
 
The Grand Final  This House believes that autocracy is doomed in the age of Facebook

Other motions for the upcoming tournament in August will be announced one hour before their respective rounds.

The members of the Motions Committee for this year's WSDC are:  Mehvesh Mumtaz Ahmed, Christopher Bishop, Thepparith (TJ) Senamngern, Eva Spoor, and Cameron Wyllie.  Simon Quinn is the current chair. 

The Chief Adjudicators of the 2011 Dundee WSDC are: Beth James and Andrew Marshall.

---------------
Follow us on Twitter @debateIndonesia
Write to us at editorial.board.idebate@gmail.com 


Wednesday, June 1, 2011

2011 WSDC - Prepared Motions to be launched on June 1, 2011

In a message published at the 2011 World Schools Debating Championship (WSDC) website, Beth James (Co-CA of the 2011 Dundee WSDC) announced that prepared motions for the 2011 WSDC will be deployed today, at midday GMT (that's 6pm in Jakarta). 

Her message is replicated below:

---------------

Dear all

I am pleased to announce that the prepared motions for WSDC Dundee will be released at midday GMT on 1st June 2011. The motions will be uploaded as a PDF document on the official WSDC Dundee website http://wsdctournament.wordpress.com and I will publish the URL link to access this document on the Netpals and registered participant mailing lists and on the main WSDC website, facebook page and blog. 

Regards

Beth James
Co-CA WSDC Dundee 2011

---------------
Follow us on Twitter @debateIndonesia
Write to us on editorial.board.idebate@gmail.com

2011 NSDC Championships - Aceh Team Edges over Bali in Close Final

Team Aceh triumphed over tournament favorite Team Bali in a very close match at last night's 2011 National Schools Debating Championships (2011 NSDC).  Debating the motion THBT Establishing Democracy through Military Force is Justifiable, the team from SMA Model Bangsa took 5 of the 9 adjudication votes from the SMA 4 Denpasar team, which recently won the ALSA UI (high school) debates.


The NSDC has been sponsored annually by the Indonesian Ministry of Education, in a program which started in 2000 (then called the High School Debating Camp).  The top speakers from the NSDC are included in a shortlist of candidates from which Indonesia's representatives to the World Schools Debating Championships are chosen. 

Congratulations to both teams, and to all the speakers who made it to the top speaker spots!

---------------
Follow us on Twitter @debateIndonesia
Write to us at editorial.board.idebate@gmail.com